Margins across hospitality have rarely been under such intense pressure.
Operators are navigating rising wages, increasing energy costs, supplier inflation and higher taxes, all while trying to maintain the value that guests expect when dining out. The result is a constant balancing act: protect profitability without pushing prices so far that customers feel priced out.
Many businesses attempt to solve this problem in the most obvious way – raising prices or trimming portions. But those decisions are often made with incomplete information.
Sales data alone only tells part of the story.
What it doesn’t show is how guests actually feel about each dish on the menu, how value perception changes as prices move, or which items are quietly undermining the guest experience.
That’s where true menu engineering begins.
The problem with traditional menu analysis
Most menu decisions are made using a simple formula: identify best-selling dishes and protect them, while removing items that don’t sell.
But popularity does not always equal profitability, and poor sales don’t always mean a dish is failing.
In many cases, dishes underperform because of small issues – presentation, value perception, portion size or positioning on the menu. Others sell well despite low guest satisfaction simply because they are familiar or safe choices.
Without deeper insight, businesses risk removing dishes guests love or missing opportunities to improve margin without impacting satisfaction.
A data-led approach to menu performance
Recently, a major UK casual dining brand undertook a significant transformation after a challenging period that saw its estate reduced in size.
To rebuild momentum, the business focused on understanding the relationship between guest experience and menu performance.
Rather than relying purely on sales reports, the team analysed:
- Guest sentiment for each dish
- How specific menu items influenced overall satisfaction
- The relationship between dish ratings and value perception
- Price sensitivity across the menu
This created a clearer picture of which dishes were truly driving the brand’s success and which ones needed improvement.
The insight informed the most extensive menu refresh in the brand’s history.
What the data revealed
Guest insight played a central role in shaping the new offer.
Fifty new dishes were introduced, with a large portion of the core grill range rebuilt from the ground up. The development focused on flavour, variety and customisation – areas where guests showed the strongest engagement.
The results were immediate.
- Seven of the eight best-performing appetisers and six of the top eight mains came from these newly designed dishes.
- At the same time, several existing menu items improved significantly once refinements were made, with dish satisfaction scores rising from the mid-80s into the 90s.
- Overall dish ratings across the estate reached an average score of 87 out of 100, exceeding internal targets.
- Comparing the month leading up to the menu launch and the month post launch, across all core ratings the group saw an average 2% increase.
- Value perception was the highest improvement with a 4% boost in LFL ratings.
Some categories performed particularly strongly:
- Breakfast, brunch, desserts and cocktails all achieved satisfaction scores above 90%.
- Consistency across venues improved dramatically, with the number of locations delivering 90+ dish satisfaction increasing by 50%.
The commercial impact
Better menu design translated into measurable commercial improvements.
- Like-for-like covers increased by 10% within months of the launch, while grill category sales rose from 17% of total sales to 28%.
- Perceived value also improved. The proportion of guests who felt the brand was less expensive than competitors increased from 9% to 16%.
This is a crucial insight in today’s environment. Guests are not simply reacting to price – they are reacting to value. When menus are built around what customers genuinely enjoy, price increases become far less damaging.
The bigger lesson for hospitality
The most successful operators are moving beyond instinct-led menu design and embracing a more scientific approach.
Menu engineering today means understanding the complex relationship between:
- Guest sentiment
- Price elasticity
- Dish performance
- Perceived value
- Operational delivery
When those factors are analysed together, opportunities quickly emerge.
Margins can often improve by small adjustments – refining portion sizes, repositioning dishes, improving recipes, or optimising pricing on items where guest demand is strongest.
Even a small improvement across an entire menu can unlock significant hidden revenue.
Insight as a competitive advantage
Hospitality has always been a creative industry built on great food and memorable experiences.
But in today’s economic climate, insight has become just as important as creativity.
Operators who truly understand how their menus perform, both financially and emotionally with guests, are better equipped to make confident decisions.
And in a market where every percentage point of margin matters, that clarity can be the difference between simply surviving and building real momentum.
The future of menu design isn’t guesswork – it’s insight.
Want to see how 125 Data & Insights works for yourself? Book a demo with out team today: